The test of a New York slice is whether you can fold it. Pick it up, give it the lengthwise fold, and watch what happens: does the tip hold, or does it flop and drip? At Frankie & Joe’s on West Palmetto Park Road, it holds. Thin, foldable, with sauce that tastes like actual tomatoes. For a city that has argued for years about whether you can get a real slice in South Florida, that is the whole ballgame.

What You’re Getting Into

Order the plain cheese first. It is the honest measure of any pizzeria, and this one passes: a thin crust with a little crackle on the bottom, cheese pulled right, and an organic tomato sauce that reads bright instead of sweet. If you want to see the kitchen flex, get the Margherita with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a finish of good olive oil.

From there the menu goes deeper than slices. The Grandma square is the one to beat, with fresh mozzarella and basil over a crispy, well-oiled bottom. There are calzones stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmigiano, plus a row of signature handhelds built on seeded pizza rolls. The meatball parm, homemade meatballs and melted mozzarella, is the sleeper order that turns first-timers into regulars.

This is casual, order-at-the-counter pizza done the right way. You are not here for the dining room. You are here because someone finally decided to make the slice the way it is made up north and put it right off downtown Boca.

The Insider Move

Go at lunch when the pies are coming out of the oven fresh. A hot slice straight off the deck is a different food than one that has sat under the warmer. If you are feeding a group, call ahead for a whole pie and add a calzone or the Grandma square for the table. Curbside pickup and delivery are both there when you are in a rush, but the slice is best eaten standing at the counter, folded, the way it is meant to be.

What People Are Saying

Frankie & Joe’s hit the local radar fast. Reviewers keep landing on the same verdict: finally, a New York-style slice that actually delivers, with a sauce that has real tang and a cheese pull people cannot stop mentioning. One regular called it maybe the best pizza in Boca, full stop. The Grandma square gets singled out for its crispy bottom and fresh basil, the meatball parm has its own fan club, and more than a few reviews mention how fast the delivery shows up, hot.

No big backstory needed here. The sauce is organic, the slices come out thin and foldable, and the whole thing is built around getting one slice exactly right.

Subscribe to The 561 Scoop, the free weekly newsletter covering Boca Raton’s best food, events, and things to do. Every Sunday in your inbox.